Aristotle maintains that every man has, or should have, a single end. The special theory of relativity raises a problem for this view. But for aristotle the happy man is neither a noble savage, nor man in his natural state, but the educated man. The module presents the ethical views of aristotle and kant by focusing on the fundamental question of normative ethics. Or, click on one of the links below to jump directly to the topic of your choice.
The practical import of aristotle s doctrine of the mean 3 trivial and obvious4 platitudinous and a practical futility barnes, 26. What makes it so slippery is its long history, and the many uses to which the word has been put. Aristotle also says 220b5 there is the same time everywhere at once this remark somehow seems importantly true, but then what could at once mean that wouldnt trivialize the remark. Why so many philosophers are unhappy about happiness via aristotle or the ratio as the true principle of the aristotelian eudaimonia the main issue of aristotelian ethics is how to reach eudaimonia happiness, and there is the endless argument in the modern angloamerican interpretation of aristotelianism re. To browse through the entire bibliography, simply page down. Virtue and phronesis in aristotle s ethics jessica moss penultimate draft final version in phronesis 56, 2011 1.
Aristotle develops his theory of moral responsibility mainly in book iii of the nicomachean ethics, where he claims we are held responsible for our voluntary actions and thus liable to either praise or blame, whereas for our involuntary actions we may be liable to either pardon or pity. Irwin, aristotle s nicomachean ethics notes and glossary and aristotle s first principles, esp. Ackril1, cooper and white present the inclusive view whereas hardie, kenny, and kraut present the dominant view. In this essay, i offer an account of what aristotle means by function and what the human function is, drawing on aristotle s metaphysical and psychological writings. Vii of the nichomachean ethics by aristotle introduction in book seven of the nicomachean ethics, aristotle sets out his theory of akrasia, or weakness of will. Responsibility and justice in aristotles nonvoluntary. Hardie was born on 25 april 1902 in edinburgh, scotland to william hardie, classical scholar. Aristotle and contemporary political theory instructor. There are two nonegoistic interpretations of aristotle s ethical theory i will not. Burnet, who held that the en is dialectical throughout p. It is sometimes referred to in comparison to later ethical theories as a character based ethics. Aristotles ethics and moral responsibility by javier.
It is difficult to tell which one of these schools of thought is a true representation of aristotle s view of eudaimonia, without reading aristotle s nicomachean ethics. This is a study of aristotles moral philosophy as it is contained in the nicomachean ethics. The mean as required by continuous and divisible feelings and actions is discussed on pp. Ethics, morals, and ethical theory other bibliographies. Aristotle reading group 200708 1 further reading on the nicomachean ethics1 standard greek critical edition. Similarity between aristotle and kants moral goodness. Sarah broadie, aristotle and contemporary ethics philpapers. Hence, articles on aristotle s ethics, politics, rhetoric, poetics, etc. Aristotles ethics is a common sense ethics built on naturalism and selfrealization. Aristotles poetics and the problem of tragic conflict. This module discusses two of the most important and influential moral theories in the history of philosophy. Increasing dissatisfaction with these theories and their variants has led in recent years to the emer. Contemporary virtue ethics and aristotle peter simpson lyloral philosophy has long been dominated by two basic theo ries, kantianism or deontology on the one hand, and utilitarianism or consequentialism on the other. The practical import of aristotles doctrine of the mean.
Aristotle attempts to explain both how such actions are possible contra socrates, and how we can dissolve the puzzles aporiai generated by our most important kurios commonly held. Aristotle s version of the argument in particular has provoked a great deal of criticism, some of which i describe in the next section. He studied classics at balliol college, oxford, graduating with a double first bachelor of arts ba degree in 1924. This is a persistent sort of problem in philosophy of time. Aristotle s ethical works are teaching manuals on the art of living. Dellis 1 summary the meaning of hexis in aristotle s bioethical philosophy we know that aristotle coined the adjective and used it to describe the writings which we now call ethics. The first half of the course will be devoted to reading. A critique of aristotles conception of eudemonia in the. But, of course, we would not be aware of an imperceptible process. See jeff dsouza, the selfabsorption objection and neoaristotelian virtue ethics, american catholic philosophical quarterly published online.
Aristotle s ethics develops a complex theory of the qualities which make for a good human being and for several decades there has been intense discussion about whether aristotle s theory of voluntariness, outlined in the ethics, actually delineates what modern thinkers would recognize as a theory of moral responsibility. Hardie, magnanimity in aristotle s ethics wed, feb 6. Corrective justice, however fair, is not shown to lead to any improvements, except insofar as it might be better to allow the taking of an eye for an eye instead of an eye, ear, nose and throat. This bibliography was generated on cite this for me on saturday, september 19, 2015.
Aristotle s ethics, or study of character, is built around the premise that people should achieve an excellent character a virtuous character, ethike arete in greek as a precondition for attaining happiness or wellbeing eudaimonia. General studies of aristotelian ethics that have helped me are by hardie, w. Similarity between aristotle and kants moral goodness question. Longmans, green, 1907, also by chapter 69 aristotle. This book turns a philosophical lens on to the main themes of aristotles ethics, offering detailed discussions of happiness as an end, virtue, character development, voluntary agency, prohairesis rational choice, practical wisdom, incontinence, pleasure, and the theoretic. Of all the classical theories considered here, his is the farthest from an ethics of selfinterest. The meaning of hexis in aristotle s bioethical philosophy by panagiotis a. He was educated at edinburgh academy, then an allboys independent school. The happy man, the good man, is a virtuous man, but virtue is acquired precisely through education. The first principle we have arrived at the definition of happiness given above must be tested logically, as a conclusion drawn from premises, and also in the light of generally held opinions on the nature of happiness, for something that is true will be found to be in harmony with all the evidence. Aristotles ethical theory william francis ross hardie on. It is not surprising that when the doctrine of the mean is viewed as a meta ethical thesis, it should appear to possess no substantive content.
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content aristotle s metaphysics of morals eugene garver the ethical virtues, as defined by aristotle, do not fit in any simple way into the classification of powers in the metaphysics,as rational or irrational w. If, then, there is some end of the things we do which we desire for its own sake everything else being desired for the sake of this, and if we do not choose everything for the sake of something else for at that rate the process would go. With respect to the good, right, happiness, the good is not a disposition. This barcode number lets you verify that youre getting exactly the right version or edition of a book. This is a study of aristotle s moral philosophy as it is contained in the nicomachean ethics. This course will provide students with an intensive study of aristotle s ethical and political thought. Chapter v varying views of the good life summary it is generally assumed that a mans idea of happiness and the good is derived from the kind of life he leads. Jeff dsouza makes a powerful case that no neoaristotelian form of virtue ethics has managed to escape the charge of egoism. Joseph wanyama situma1 abstract this paper is concerned with the problem of interpreting aristotle s conception of eudemonia in his treatise, nicomachean ethics which will henceforth be referred to in its abbreviated form as ne. This book turns a philosophical lens on to the main themes of aristotles ethics, offering detailed discussions of happiness as an end, virtue, character development, voluntary agency, prohairesis rational choice, practical wisdom, incontinence, pleasure, and the theoretic ideal.
909 532 116 1558 1290 1444 1236 923 25 760 1507 662 1178 550 669 12 369 1415 673 470 437 781 307 72 1291 1290 381 1505 721 1582 536 692 941 1346 1394 999 9 1255 195 1159 713 1423 916 695 448